Contact Us About Us Community Consumer Agents Careers

Pay my Bill

To make a payment, you will be prompted to enter your Policy Number and the Zip Code as it appears on your billing statement. Please include any leading zeros. Please note if your policy information does not appear, you cannot use this service. You would need to contact your Badger Mutual Agent.


ID Cards

To print your current ID Cards, you will be prompted to enter your Policy Number and the Zip Code as it appears on your billing statement. Please include any leading zeros. Please note if your policy information does not appear, you cannot use this service and would need to contact an accounts representative listed on the right.


Payment History

To review your last five payments, you will be prompted to enter your Policy Number and the Zip Code as it appears on your billing statement. Please include any leading zeros. Please note if your policy information does not appear, you cannot use this service and would need to contact an accounts representative listed on the right.


Report a Claim

If this matter involves a fire, serious injury or requires immediate attention, contact the home office at 1-800-837-7833 during normal business hours. If the office is closed, please contact 1-866-223-4371.

To report a claim, the Name, Address and Policy Number (if known) of Badger Mutual's policyholder will be required. A claims representative will contact you on the next business day.


Add/Change E-mail Address

Please provide your e-mail address by clicking on the blue button to the right.  You will need your Policy Number and Zip Code.

Your e-mail address will not be shared with any third parties and we will not fill your inbox with unneeded messages.


I Have Received a Letter

If you have received a letter allowing you the option to go online and take action, begin by clicking on the blue button to the right.  You will need your Policy Number and Zip Code.

Questions about payment options?

Please call Margaret, Accounts Supervisor at (414) 383-1234, ext. 659 or (800) 837-7833.


Questions about the claim process?

Please contact Badger Mutual’s Claims Dept. at
1-800-837-7833.